Cleaner Technology Projects in Denmark 1997

Environmental Management of a Worn-out Industrial Area in Herning

Miljørigtig projektering af udtjent industriområde i Herning
Arbejdsrapport nr. 37, 1997, Miljøstyrelsen

This report is part of a succession of work reports in phase 2 of the frame project "Environmental Management". The result of phase 2 is "A Guide to Environmental Management" which consists of method descriptions, guidelines, environmental data and examples. In connection with the development of the guide, the principles of environmental management are tested in a number of concrete demonstration projects, including the present project, which deals with the environmental management of a worn out industrial area.  

The frame project is initiated by The Danish Environmental Protection Agency and The National Council for Recycling and Less Polluting Technologies and implemented under the management of The Danish Association of Consulting Engineers, F.R.I., in co-operation with the Danish Council of Practising Architects, PAR, The Danish Building Research Institute, The Danish Technological Institute and several builders’ organisations.

In 1994 phase 1 was concluded by publishing The Danish Environmental Protection Agency’s Environment Project No. 253 with basic guidelines for environmental management in project design.

A three-year long phase 2 encompasses further development and operationalization of methods of environmental management in project design. A public hearing in 1997 will conclude phase 2.

The most essential result of phase 2 is "Håndbog i Miljørigtig Projektering" (A guide to Environmental Management in Project Design) which consists of descriptions of methods, directions, environmental data and examples. While preparing the guide, principles of environmental management in project design were tested by a number of demonstration projects - including the present demonstration project on the conversion of a worn-out industrial area to an environmentally sustainable housing area in Herning Municipality. The project is also called DP7.

DP7 has been an integrated part of Byomdannelsesprojektet for Thrigesvejområdet (The City Conversion Project for the area around Thrige’s Street) in Herning Municipality. The project is initiated to realise the political decision - presented in the Municipality Plan - of converting a worn-out industrial area to a sustainable housing area.

Parallel to DP7’s project period, Herning Municipality has been preparing a masterplan in relation to The City Conversion Project In connection with DP7 an environmental programme and an environmental activity plan with the purpose of integrating the environmental programme into the masterplan were prepared.

The environmental programme and the activity plan sets out the framework and guidelines for coming projects in the area, including both demolition and construction projects.

The main environmental problem in DP7 was the fact that it is not possible to make environmental objectives outlined in the environmental programme legally binding in the masterplan or succeeding local plans. Planloven (The Danish Planning Law) does not allow this opportunity. Therefore the environmental activity plan presents inspiration, goodwill and voluntariness as ways of realising The City Conversion Project.

Another main problem is a number of economic barriers to the realisation of The City Conversion Project. The primary barrier is the scope for making the future economically sustainable for the companies in the area. It is a barrier during the conversion and in the case that the companies move out. It was proposed to establish a development company to meet these barriers.

In the environmental activity plan the development company’s environmental management is proposed to achieve the environmental objectives and targets outlined in the environmental programme. But in reality the development company can do as it wishes.

From an environmental point of view a phase 1 of The City Conversion Project can be initiated north of Tietgensgade (Tietgen’s Street), if one company moves from the area or reduces noise nuisances from production activities. More environmental analysis is needed before initiating succeeding phases.

Guidelines for introducing environmental sound measures are also presented in the environmental programme - for example less polluting technology and recycling of building materials. Furthermore, there are a number of ecological measures listed. A community group that forms part of a local Agenda 21activities in Herning Municipality suggested these measures. The ecological measures have to be environmentally assessed in coming projects as they are not necessarily environmentally sound according to the principles presented in A Guide to Environmental Management in project design.

Environmental management in project design has been a relevant method in DP7, but the tools presented in "A Guide to Environmental Management" have not been of great help. The main reason is that DP7 has had an area focus and the guide is - at the present stage - primarily focused on buildings.

The town planners in Herning Municipality expressed that the environmental focus - introduced to The City Conversion Project by DP7 - has been an important and positive input into the traditional planning procedure.

One important experience from DP7’s work is that consultants have to be very well prepared to present environmental management in project design to clients and especially the consequences that are different from traditional project design. A clear presentation of method and tools in "A Guide to Environmental Management in Project Design" will be an important element in making environmental management in project design a routine for the consultant and a standard demand from the client.

Author/ institution

Herning Kommune and RAMBØLL 

This report is subsidised by the National Council for Recycling and Cleaner Production

ISSN no. 0908-9195
ISBN no. 87-7810-793-8