Buffer zones for biodiversity of plants and arthropods: is there a compromise on width?

Table 3.15. Schematic summary of the statistical analyses on diversity of epigaeic predators.

Taxa Diversity
Measure
Test results F(ndf,ddf)P¹
    Field² Distance³ Buffer4 Buffer ×
Distance5
Period6 Period ×
Buffer7
Period ×
Distance8
Period ×
Buffer ×
Distance9
Araneae
Families
Family
richness
3.46(3, 12)NS 12.32(4, 210)*** 10.67(4, 12)*** 1.99(16, 210)* 140.23(2, 210)*** 9.04(8, 210)*** 3.68(8, 210)*** 1.64(32, 210)*
Shannon´s
H
7.74(3, 12.07)** 8.73(4, 12)*** 0.46(4, 12)NS 10.54(16, 198)NS 201.67(2, 198)*** 1.93(8, 198)NS 3.02(8, 198)** 0.55(32, 198)NS
Carabidae
Species
Species
richness
21.49(3, 13.5)*** 5.58(4, 12)** 2.76(4, 12)NS 0.86(16, 198)NS 116.85(2, 198)*** 3.30(8, 198)** 2.80(8, 198)** 0.99(32, 198)NS
Shannon´s
H
22.51(3, 13.62)*** 5.32(4, 12)* 2.29(4, 12)NS 1.03(16, 198)NS 124.91(2, 198)*** 1.92(8, 198)NS 3.14(8, 198)** 1.07(32, 198)NS

¹ NS Not significant, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001. F is the F-value, ndf and ddf is the numerator and denominator degree of freedom used for testing the significance.

² Effect of field (four fields were included in the experiment).

³ Effect of distance from field edge (sampling was carried out 0, 2, 5, 9 and 18 m from the field edge).

4 Effect of buffer width (0, 4, 6, 12 and 24 m).

5 Effect of the combination of distance and buffer width (in total there were 5 × 5 = 25 combinations).

6 Three sampling periods: 1. After herbicide application (May), 2. After first insecticide application (June), 3. After second insecticide application (July).

7 Effect of buffer at each sampling period.

8 Effect of distance from field edge at each sampling period.

9 Effect of the combination of distance and buffer width at each sampling period.



Version 1.0 November 2009, © Danish Environmental Protection Agency