Evaluation of Plasticisers for PVC for Medical Devices

6 Experimental

6.1 Preparation of compounds, films and test specimens
6.1.1 Preparation of PVC compounds plasticised with the selected substances
6.1.2 Preparation by injection moulding of specimens for material characterisation
6.1.3 Preparation by roll milling of film samples for testing
6.2 Characterisation of the prepared compounds and of the alternative non-PVC material
6.2.1 Tensile properties determined on injection moulded specimens
6.2.2 Density of the prepared compounds
6.2.3 Indentation hardness determined on square injection moulded specimens
6.2.4 Cold flexibility
6.2.5 Tensile properties determined on roll milled film specimens
6.2.6 Light transmission determined on roll milled film specimens
6.3 Total assessment 

6.1 Preparation of compounds, films and test specimens

6.1.1 Preparation of PVC compounds plasticised with the selected substances

Approx. 25 kg of test compounds based on each of the selected substances as a plasticiser were prepared and pelletised at Hydro Polymers with the compositions shown in Table 3 below.

As a reference compound a standard DEHP plasticised PVC compound with a Shore A hardness of 80 was chosen, and the Shore A hardness of the test compounds should be as near as possible to 80 for comparison reasons.

Table 3
Formulation of the prepared PVC compounds (parts by weight)

Compound No.

036

037

038

039

040

041

042

043

106

Plasticiser type

Ingredients 1)

DEHP

DINP

DEHA

DEHS

TEHTM

Ben- zoate

Polya- dipate

ATBC

EAC Terpo- lymer

PVC resin

100

100

100

100

100

100

100

100

100

Epoxidised soya bean oil

4

4

4

4

4

4

4

4

4

A calcium-zinc stabiliser

1.5

1.5

1.5

1.5

1.5

1.5

1.5

1.5

1.5

DEHP

48

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 

DINP

-

52

-

-

-

-

-

-

 

DEHA

-

-

45

-

-

-

-

-

 

DEHS

-

-

-

51

 

-

-

-

 

TEHTM

-

-

-

-

59

-

-

-

 

A benzoate

-

-

-

-

-

52

-

-

 

A polyadipate

-

-

-

-

-

-

59

-

 

ATBC

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

53

 

EAC Terpolymer

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

40

1) Sources of the ingredients are listed in appendix 3

6.1.2 Preparation by injection moulding of specimens for material characterisation

From the prepared PVC compounds dumbbell shaped tensile test specimens of type 1A according to ISO 527-2:1993 and square test specimens 4 mm thick and 50 mm in side length were made by injection moulding at the Danish Technological Institute.

The detailed injection moulding reports are enclosed as appendix 2.

Table 4 shows the injection moulding parameters used.

Table 4
Parameters used for the injection moulding of dumbbell shaped tensile test specimens and square specimens - zone, nozzle and mould temperatures [ºC]

Compound No.

036

037

038

039

040

041

042

043

106

EVAC

Plasticiser type

DEHP

DINP

DEHA

DEHS

TEHTM

Ben- zoate

Polya- dipate

ATBC

EAC Terpo- lymer

-

Zone 4

170

170

182

180

170

170

177

170

170

170

Zone 3

185

185

195

195

185

185

191

185

185

185

Zone 2

185

185

195

195

185

185

191

185

185

185

Zone 1

190

190

199

199

190

190

195

190

190

190

Nozzle

190

190

199

199

190

190

195

190

190

190

Mould

35

35

35

35

35

35

35

35

35

35

6.1.3 Preparation by roll milling of film samples for testing

From the prepared compounds 185 - 400 µm thick film samples were made by direct roll milling at PapyroTex.

The temperature of the front roll was 166ºC; the temperature of the back roll was 160ºC. Prior to testing the film samples were conditioned at room temperature for four days.

6.2 Characterisation of the prepared compounds and of the alternative non-PVC material

The test program was conducted at Danish Technological Institute, Centre for Plastics Technology except from the tensile test of film samples, which was performed at the laboratory at Papyro-Tex. The laboratory at Danish Technological Institute, Centre for Plastics Technology is accredited according to DS/EN ISO/IEC 17025 to perform a long range of tests on plastics and similar materials.

6.2.1 Tensile properties determined on injection moulded specimens

Test method: ISO 527-2, specimen type 1A. Crosshead speed 100 mm/min. The detailed test reports are enclosed in appendix 4.

Table 5
Tensile strength and tensile strain at break of injection moulded specimens from PVC test compounds and from a selected grade of EVAC (source information enclosed in appendix 3)

Compound No.

Plasticiser type

Specimen width [mm]

Specimen thickness [mm]

Tensile strength [MPa]

Tensile strain at break [%]

Mean value

Statistical standard deviation

Mean value

Statistical standard deviation

036

DEHP

9.97

3.97

14.7

0.193

234

9.31

037

DINP

10.00

3.99

14.6

0.319

238

6.59

038

DEHA

9.99

4.00

13.6

0.197

279

9.86

039

DEHS

10.00

3.00

12.6

0.234

255

16.19

040

TEHTM

10.02

4.00

14.1

0.149

196

7.65

041

Benzoate

9.99

3.97

16.8

0.216

207

3.22

042

Polyadipate

9.98

3.97

14.2

0.190

211

9.75

043

ATBC

9.99

3.98

13.9

0.262

227

9.98

106

EAC Terpo- lymer

10.00

3.96

19.7

0.166

102

2.38

Alternative plastic

EVAC

10.00

3.97

6.29

0.153

>934*)

 

*) No break at this strain
  

Fig. 1
Tensile strength of injection mouldings [MPa]
  

Fig. 2
Tensile strain at break of injection mouldings [%]

6.2.2 Density of the prepared compounds

The density of the prepared PVC compounds and of the alternative plastic material was determined on square injection moulded specimens.

Test method: ISO 2781 method A, ver. 1.

Table 6
Density determined on square injection moulded specimens

Compound No.

Plasticiser type

Density [kg/m³]

036

DEHP

1232

037

DINP

1219

038

DEHA

1212

039

DEHS

1193

040

TEHTM

1216

041

Benzoate

1292

042

Polyadipate

1259

043

ATBC

1256

106

EAC Terpolymer

1240

Alternative plastic

EVAC

951

 

Fig. 3
Density [kg/m3]

6.2.3 Indentation hardness determined on square injection moulded specimens

Test method: DS/EN ISO 868:1998 read after 15 seconds.

Table 7
Shore A hardness determined on square injection moulded specimens

Compound No.

Plasticiser type

Shore A

036

DEHP

82

037

DINP

84

038

DEHA

82

039

DEHS

82

040

TEHTM

83

041

Benzoate

80

042

Polyadipate

80

043

ATBC

78

106

EAC Terpolymer

94*)

Alternative plastic

EVAC

79

*) This value is beyond the interval valid for Shore A
 

Fig. 4
Shore A hardness

6.2.4 Cold flexibility

The cold flexibility temperature was derived from the torsional moduli at varying temperatures determined on plane-parallel specimens cut out from injection moulded tensile test specimens.

Test method: ISO 458/1-1985.

The cold flexibility temperature is defined as the temperature, at which the torsional stiffness, determined by apparent torsional modulus testing, is 310 N/mm at an angular deflection value of 200 degrees.

The resulted graphs are enclosed in appendix 5.

Table 8
Cold flexibility temperature of PVC test compounds and of a selected grade of EVAC determined by testing according to ISO 458/1-1986 [°C]. Also expected values for some compounds are shown.

Compound No.

Plasticiser or plastic material

Determined by testing

Approximate expected values *)

Approx. values expected by the project partners based on their experience

036

DEHP

- 20

- 19

- 22

½037DI

DINP

- 20

- 19

- 26

038

DEHA

< - 40

- 46

- 50

039

DEHS

< - 40

- 55

- 60

040

TEHTM

- 20

- 24

- 24

041

Benzoate

- 3

?

?

042

Polyadipate

- 10

- 13

- 13

043

ATBC

- 22

- 23

- 22

106

EAC Terpolymer

+ 11

?

?

Alternative plastic

EVAC

- 36

?

?

*) These expected values are derived from ref. 19 and interpolated to the actual hardness values
   

Fig. 5
Cold flexibility tempature [degree C]

6.2.5 Tensile properties determined on roll milled film specimens

Test methods: ISO 527-3, specimen type 2. Width 10 mm, length 150 mm and clamp distance 100 mm. Crosshead speed 200 mm/min.

Prior to testing the film samples were conditioned at room temperature for four days. The mean values were derived from five single values. These tests were performed at Papyro-Tex. The detailed test reports are enclosed in appendix 6.

Table 9
Tensile strength and tensile strain at break of film samples from PVC test compounds. Note: The EVAC material was not available in the form of film.

Compound No.

 

Plasticiser type

 

Specimen thickness [µm]

 

Tensile strength [MPa]

Tensile strain at break [%]

Mean value

Statistical standard deviation

Mean value

Statistical standard deviation

036

DEHP

250

20.08

0.36

415

7

037

DINP

210

20.56

0.26

381

7

038

DEHA

220

17.97

0.49

411

12

039

DEHS

220

14.42

0.32

350

8

040

TEHTM

220

18.18

0.45

379

5

041

Benzoate

185

21.90

0.90

296

19

042

Polyadipate

220

20.18

0.79

375

18

043

ATBC

220

19.37

0.39

371

26

106

EAC Terpolymer

400

27.70

1.05

333

20

 

Fig. 6
Tensile strength of film [MPa]
  

Fig. 7
Tensile strain at break of film [%]

6.2.6 Light transmission determined on roll milled film specimens

Test method: USP XXIV <661> with the exception for the washing and drying of the film samples and with a wider range for the light transmission measurements (290 nm to 800 nm).

Instrument model: Perkin Elmer LAMBDA 18; data interval: 1.0000 nm; scan speed: 240.00 nm/min; slit width: 2.0000 nm; smooth bandwidth: 0.00 nm.

The single light transmission graphs are enclosed in appendix 7.

Table 10
Maximum light transmission at 450 and 800 nm of film samples from PVC test compounds [%]. Note: The EVAC material was not available in the form of film.

Compound No.

Plasticiser type

@ 450 nm 3)

@ 800 nm 4)

Sample No. 1

Sample No. 2

Sample No. 1

Sample No. 2

036

DEHP

91

91

92.0

92.1

037

DINP

91

91

92.1

92.1

038

DEHA

91

91

92.2

92.3

039

DEHS

91

91

92.3

92.4

040

TEHTM

90

90

91.8

91.7

041

Benzoate

90

90

91.6

91.6

042

Polyadipate

91

91

92.2

92.2

043

ATBC

92

92

92.6

92.5

106

EAC Terpolymer

1)

2)

91

91

92.1

92.3

89

88

91.4

91.3

1) Shiny side towards the light source
2) Opposite side towards the light source
3) Read from the graphs
4) Calculated electronically by apparatus
  

Fig. 8
Light transmission of film [%]

6.3 Total assessment

Table 12 shows an attempt to make a total assessment

Table 12
Total assessment

Se her!