Denmark's Third National Communication on Climate Change

Appendix C: Description of selected programmes/projects for promotion and/or financing of technology transfer to other countries

Part I
Description of selected programmes or projects for promotion and/or financing of technology transfer to developing countries

Programme/project title: Capacity Building in Government and Related Agencies, Malaysian Energy Centre (PTM)

Objective: To enhance a wider implementation of sustainable energy solutions, renewable energy and energy efficiency, in Malaysia.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Malaysia

Energy

DKK 10.0 mill.

3

Description: The overall strategy is to design a training programme on integrated resource and energy planning targeting the relevant PTM staff, as well as participants from government agencies and related institutes and companies. The necessary tools for implementation of integrated resource and energy planning(including a computer-model and a database) will be established and hands-on training will be provided.

The following main results have been achieved:

The capacity of PTM staff, related agencies, and selected universities in energy-sector modelling has been enhanced

A data collection system and a database have been developed

A set of customised integrated energy sector analysis tools has been developed

A set of integrated analyses has been performed

A website has been developed including a database

Indicate success factors: Capacity developed among relevant members of staff.

Technology transferred: Danish experience in modelling and analysis methodology has been provided.

 

Programme/project title: Support for Development of a Strategy for Renewable Energy as the Fifth Fuel in Malaysia

Objective: To improve the environmental sustainability of energy supply by increased utilisation of renewable energy sources, including improvement of the use of energy efficiency in the end use sectors of industry and buildings.

The project aims at supporting the Ministry of Energy, Communications and Multimedia in developing implementation plans for the national strategies on energy efficiency (EE) and renewable energy (RE). The EE and RE strategies will be implemented within the context of the 8th Malaysia Plan.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Malaysia

Energy

DKK 4.7 mill.

1 year
Completed in 2000


Description:

  1. The project developed a policy on RE incorporated in the 8 Plan and a legal and financial framework for RE. This includes access to the electricity grid on transparent and acceptable terms. The project also looked into financial and fiscal incentives and provided a strong organisational support and increased the level of awareness on the benefits of utilising RE.

  2. In addition the project achieved the development of a Malaysian Energy Management Programme which included the role of the public administration in Malaysia as a catalyst for establishment of a market for EE technology and promotion of RE in an open electricity market as well as a visit to Denmark for high-level decision makers in Malaysia.

Indicate success factors: An objective of 5% energy supply from renewable energy sources was implemented in the 8th Malaysian Plan

 

Programme/project title: Support for Development of an Energy Efficiency Strategy in Malaysia

Objective: To improve the efficiency of the use of energy in the end use sectors of industry and buildings.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Malaysia

Energy

DKK 2.0 mill.

Completed in 2000

  1. Description: The achieved establishment of financial support for EE activities comprising a comprehensive fiscal package and the establishment of an Energy Business Fund which can disburse funds efficiently and expeditiously to EE and RE Projects in Malaysia. Another result was an implementation plan for a Malaysian Energy Management Programme that gives EE due recognition in government procurement, and energy management of government facilities

Indicate success factors: The project recommendations are reflected in the 2001 Budget and 8th Malaysia Plan and an energy efficiency strategy was developed.

 

Programme/project title: Centre for Education and Training for Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency

Objective: Renewable energies and energy efficiency are regarded as viable means for Malaysia to reduce dependence on fossil fuels and improve the environment. The objective of the project is to increase the role and utilisation of renewable energy and energy efficiency in public schools and universities.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Malaysia

Energy

DKK 9.5 mill.

3 years


Description:
The project aims to establish a Centre for Education and Training for Renewable Energy (RE) and Energy Efficiency (EE) in Malaysia. This will be equipped with publicity materials, training modules, portable exhibition kit, a website and necessary office equipment to carry out training and dissemination activities in RE and EE. The project will also develop education and training materials in RE and EE for schools and universities.

Indicate success factors: The project has suggested initiating the establishment of a long-term plan to serve as an input for the scheduled mid-term review of 8th Malaysian Plan in second half of 2003. This is reflected in the 2001 Budget and 8th Malaysia Plan.

 

Programme/project title: Energy Efficient Building Design for MECM as Key Demonstration Building for Energy Use Performance and Environmental Qualities in Malaysia

Objective:

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Malaysia

Energy

DKK 9.5 mill.

3 years


Description: The Ministry of Energy, Communications and Multimedia (MECM) will move to a new building in the new Federal Government Administrative Centre, Putrajaya by the end of 2003. It is the intention of the MECM that the MECM Building in Putrajaya is to be a model building with leading-edge communications and multimedia facilities, low energy consumption and with minimal impact upon the environment. The focus is on energy use performance and environmental qualities. This means that the building design process will be based on an energy-conscious concept, taking into consideration the various aspects of building design, such as geographical orientation, the choice of outer layer of the building, energy efficient lighting and cooling system and overall integrated control and monitoring of the building utilities, functions, etc.

Indicate success factors: The team consisting of the CTA, local consultants and one short-term Danish expatriate, has worked successfully with the team of the developers of MECM Building. The project has been extended with a second phase and the building is under construction to be completed by end 2003.

On the awareness side, the project has created a lot of interest among public institutions and private building practitioners, architects, engineers, and building developers. This was evident from their active participation in the various workshops conducted during the project. A request for additional follow-up activities has been approved.

Technology transferred: Danish experience and methodology on building design features, energy saving features etc.

 

Programme/project title: Zafarana wind farm in Egypt

Objective: To contribute to Egypt's economic development by means of environmentally sound electricity production based on wind power.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Egypt

Energy

Contribution DKK 253 mill.

Credit scheme DKK 175 mill.

6


Description: The project is the first commercial wind farm in Egypt. It followed up on preliminary Danish assistance projects that included a wind atlas, planning of wind turbine centres and the construction of a demonstration wind farm. The wind farm, which has a total capacity of 60 MW, is divided into two phases. Phase 1, 30 MW, was built in 1999-2001 and phase 2 began at the end of 2002.

Technology transferred: Danish wind power technology.

Effect of emissions on greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): Substitution of fossil fuels with wind power.

 

Programme/project title: Adjustments to the Building Energy Code, Thailand.

Objective: The project is intended to help create a qualified basis for adjustment of the part of Thailand's building regulations that concerns the energy consumption from buildings.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Thailand

Energy

DKK 11.8 mill.

3


Description: The project is intended to provide support to those responsible for the part of Thailand's building regulations that concerns energy consumption in order to create a qualified basis for adjustment of the regulations. Account is taken of the latest developments within building design and technological and climatic differences across the country – factors that have so far been neglected. The revised building regulations on energy consumption will be designed to enable their incorporation in future comprehensive building regulations covering all technical aspects of the building sector. The results of analyses and studies of energy-efficient building design will be made available to all relevant parties within the building sector in order to increase awareness of the possibilities for energy savings in buildings.

Technology transferred: Danish experience with administration and regulation in the building sector and means of checking compliance with the building regulations will be made available to the Thai authorities.

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): By reducing energy use in buildings, which is largely based on fossil fuels, CO2 emissions is reduced.

 

Programme/project title: Provincial Programme for Sustainable Energy in Thailand.

Objective: To identify, plan and implement renewable energy solutions at provincial and village level and to strengthen NGOs, educational institutions, and authorities in their use of renewable energy.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Thailand

Energy

DKK 8.8 mill.

3


Description:
Geographically, the target area is the Isaan region in northeast Thailand. Project activities include collection of data, preparation of RE plans at village level, implementation of RE projects, training in RE technology, information on renewable energy, seminars on renewable energy and establishment of three renewable energy and environment centres. Renewable energy technology will be promoted through support for actual projects showing alternatives to centralised fossil-based energy production.

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): By promoting alternatives to fossil fuel-based energy production, greenhouse gas emissions will be reduced.

 

Part II
Description of selected DANCEE projects or programmes for promotion and/or financing of technology transfer to Central and Eastern European countries concerning environmentally sustainable technologies

Programme/project title: Kiev District Heating Rehabilitation

Objective: To reduce energy consumption and thus CO2 through replacement of equipment at 33 substations with modern, mainly Danish-made, energy-efficient equipment.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Ukraine

Energy

Danish Environmental Protection Agency DKK 10 mill.

Kyivenergo approx. DKK 5 mill.

20 years


Description: In connection with a major renovation of the transmission grid and  the construction of new CHP plants, the Danish Environmental Protection Agency demonstrated the possibilities for energy savings in this part of the production-transmission-distribution grid through the establishment of 33 energy-efficient substations. As a result, Kyivenergo now wants to redirect some of a USD 200 mill. World Bank loan to investments in the distribution grid, including a large number of new substations based on the Danish model. The Environmental Assistance scheme financed consulting services and equipment, while Kyivenergo paid for design, installation, etc.

Besides the work on the distribution grid, CO2-foamed (Danish) district heating pipes were supplied to some of the apartment buildings affected.

Indicate success factors: The biggest possible energy saving to convince Kyivenergo that it is right to implement energy savings in the distribution grid.

Technology transferred: Equipment for substations in the district heating grid and supply of district heating pipes.

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): Documented CO2-displacement: 7,100 t/year

 

Programme/project title: Establishment of three natural gas-fired CHP plants in Decin

Objective: To reduce emissions of CO2, SO2, NOX, and particulate, improve the health situation in the town and improve security of supply.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Czech Republic

District heating/ energy

DKK 130 mill.

Bynov 1996 Zelenice 1997
CZT 2001/2002

Description: Closure of many coal-fired district-heating plants in the town of Decin, which has a population of about 70,000.

Establishment of three natural gas-fired CHP plants covering the need for heat in the town's three districts.

The plant in Bynov was the Czech Republic's first natural gas-fired CHP plant. It was opened in October 1996 by Mr. Skalicky, the Czech Minister for the Environment at that time. The event attracted a lot of media attention. Besides the CHP plants, the town's district heating grid was renovated with Danish district heating pipes.

The switch to natural gas and the establishment of two of the CHP plants have resulted in a big reduction in dust emissions, with directly measurable effects on the population's health. Before the project Decin had the Czech Republic's highest child mortality and the largest number of people with respiratory diseases – more than twice the average number. Total support: DKK 23 mill.

Indicate success factors: Better public health

Technology transferred: Natural gas-fired CHP plants, pre-insulated district heating pipes, other equipment, client consultancy, invitation for tenders

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): Reduction of 65,000 tonnes lignite per year and 2,400 tonnes heavy fuel per year. The reductions, including the CZT plant, are as follows:

CO2
SO2
Smog

140,000 tonnes/year
480 tonnes/year
130 tonnes/year

 

Programme/project title: Establishment of woodchip-fired plant at Petroffskoye District Heating Plant

Objective: Reduction of emissions of CO2, SO2, NOX and particulates, together with deposition of coal ash. Development of the local economy on the basis of utilisation of local biomass to replace fossil fuels from other regions of Russia.

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Russia

District heat/energy

DKK 5.2 mill.

2001


Description: An old, inefficient, coal-fired district heating plant has been replaced by a modern, fully automatic woodchip-fired plant (4 MW) made in Denmark. DANCEE grant: DKK 4.2 mill. The plant is not completely financially viable because of considerable price subsidies for heating purposes in Russia. For oil-fired plants, changing to woodchip firing is viable, but lack of financing possibilities and big import taxes on woodchip firing equipment is preventing further spread of the technology for the time being. Use of local biomass waste from the timber industry is contributing to economic growth and employment in the local area.

Technology transferred: Equipment for firing with wood waste in district heating boilers with dust filters and monitoring equipment.

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): Expected CO2 displacement: 9,900 tonnes

 

Programme/project title: Use of sawdust for heat supply in Tasca, Rumania

Objective: To establish a heat supply for the village of Tasca and solve a waste problem – sawdust

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Rumania

Energy
Waste

Approx. DKK 8.5 mill.

1999


Description: In Rumania sawdust is generally regarded as waste and a great deal of it is deposited unlawfully in the countryside and often along riverbanks. The village used to receive district heat from a nearby cement factory, but when the factory was privatised to a German group, it was announced that the district heat supply was going to be discontinued. A new, sawdust-fired boiler plant with a capacity of 2.5 MW was therefore established, together with a new district heating grid with pre-insulated district heating pipes connecting the boiler plant to all consumers. Connection units for production of hot utility water for the individual buildings were supplied and fitted. A structure was established for collecting sawdust from the small sawmills in the district. Total cost of Danish consultancy and equipment: DKK 8,380,737.

Indicate success factors:

Technology transferred: Complete boiler plant, pre-insulated district heating pipes and exchange units for connection of consumers

 

Programme/project title: Establishment of a geothermal plant for supplying district heat to Zakopane and Nowy Targ in southern Poland

Objective: Reduction of emissions in the area, closure of existing coal-fired district heating plants and private cup burners, and utilisation of a local, clean source of energy

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Poland

District heat/energy

USD 95 mill.

Peak load plant 1999
Geothermal plant 2001


Description: In 1980 hot groundwater was discovered at a depth of 2,000 metres in connection with exploratory drilling for oil. After a number of teething problems the Danish Environmental Protection Agency became involved in the project in 1992 and, among other things, provided support to make the project viable, both technologically and financially. Various feasibility studies, preliminary design, design, establishment of organisation, equipment supplies, etc. have been carried out. When completed, the plant is intended to supply heat to the main towns Zakopane and Nowy Targ and villages between them, in all to about 80,000 people. At the present time, with the peak-load plant supplying Zakopane with district heat, there is already a visible improvement of the environment, which is important because the town is Poland's largest winter sports area. Total Danish support: DKK 24 mill.

Indicate success factors: Improved public health and a clean town mean more tourists (now 3 million per year)

Technology transferred: Equipment, pre-insulated district heating pipes, exchangers, which are called Redan in the area, etc., design, financial analyses, building up of organisation, etc.

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible):

CO2
SO2
NOX
Particulates

210,000 tonnes/year
1,200 tonnes/year
800 tonnes/year
540 tonnes/year

 

Programme/project title: Establishment of natural gas-fired CHP plant in the town of Põlva in Estonia

Objective: To contribute to sustainable energy use through demonstration of natural gas-based CHP (through transfer of technology and know-how)

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Estonia

Energy

DKK 5,600,000 mill.

2


Description: The project was the establishment of a small-scale natural gas-fired CHP plant in the town of Põlva (1 MW electricity and 1.2 MW heat). The project included a feasibility study, installation of a CHP plant, contracting for access to the electricity grid and sale of electricity to third parties, together with dissemination of knowledge about possibilities for establishing CHP in Estonia (through a seminar and a brochure).

Indicate success factors: High-efficiency CHP plant established. The plant has been in operation for two years. The project has resulted in the following reduction of emissions: CO2 7,849 tonnes/year, SO2 111 tonnes/year, NOx 3.2 tonnes/year, particulates 60 tonnes/year and ash 5,551 tonnes/year.

Technology transferred: CHP plant established

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): Yearly reduction in CO2 emission: 7,849 tonnes/year

 

Programme/project title: Demonstration and training project on use of wind energy

Objective: To support the construction of a Russian resource base for handling wind energy and to promote expansion of wind energy in Russia

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Russia

Energy

DKK 9 mill.

2


Description:
A wind farm comprising 20 x 225 kW turbines was established under Danish supervision. An intensive training programme was carried out at the same time for knowledge transfer concerning establishment of wind farms, turbine operation, connecting to the electricity system, etc.

Indicate success factors: A functioning wind farm making a CO2-less contribution to Kaliningrad's electricity supply and a Russian resource base of trained technicians within wind energy utilisation

Technology transferred: Danish wind turbines and know-how

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): It is assumed that the displaced electricity in Yantarenergo's supply region came from an oil-fired power station (built in 1935) with an electrical efficiency of 30%. The wind farm, which comprises 20 turbines and has a total capacity of 4.5 MW, is designed to yield almost 2,000 full-load hours/year with an electricity production of around 9,000 MWh/year. CO2 displacement will be about 7,900 tonnes/year.

 

Programme/project title: Assistance to Estonia's Ministry of Economic Affairs in connection with preparation and implementation of the EU SAVE Directive 93/76

Objective: To contribute to sustainable energy use through the establishment of effective programmes for energy efficiency improvement in end use (households, public buildings and industry)

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Estonia

Energy

DKK 1,700,000

1


Description: The project comprised assistance to the Energy Department of the Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs in connection with the preparation and implementation of the EU SAVE Directive 93/76: Establishment of energy inspection and energy management programme for industry and establishment of a programme for energy labelling of buildings. The EU Directive, which is based on the Climate Convention, is aimed at reducing Member States' CO2 emission through improved energy efficiency. The energy saving potential in end consumption in Estonia is estimated to be around 30%.
The project did not include equipment.
The project was completed in 2002.

Indicate success factors: Establishment of energy saving programmes that are resulting in energy savings and thus in reduced CO2 emission.

Technology transferred: Transfer of know-how and knowledge

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): The project has a big potential for reducing CO2 emissions.

 

Programme/project title: Energy inspection at Smolensk CHP Plant No. 2.

Objective: Feasibility study to demonstrate potential for savings at power stations

Recipient country

Sector

Total funding

Year(s) in function

Russia

Energy

DKK 400,000

2


Description: The project identified 10 different savings measures – six in the electricity sector and four in the heat sector. The potential for electricity savings is in the order of 180,000 – 7,500,000 kWh/year, while the potential for heat savings ranges from 4,000 GJ to 190,000 GJ per year. The payback times range from about one month to 11_ years, with an average payback time of 2_ years for all 10 measures. The total investment for implementation of the proposed measures has been calculated at approximately USD 930,000.

Indicate success factors: It has been proven that, as expected, big savings and very short payback times can be achieved.

Technology transferred: Transfer of know-how and knowledge

Effect on emissions of greenhouse gases/sinks (if possible): If implemented, all the saving measures investigated will result in a reduction in CO2 emission.